By: Leandra Lederman
Susan Morse and Stephen Shay have blogged today on Procedurally Taxing about the Ninth’s Circuit oral argument tomorrow in Altera Corp. v. Commissioner, as has Dan Shaviro on his blog, Start Making Sense. Altera is the transfer pricing and administrative law case involving the Treasury’s cost-sharing agreement regulation. The Tax Court invalidated the regulation under the Administrative Procedure Act, as arbitrary and capricious. That is because the Tax Court accepted the taxpayer’s argument that it need not share stock-based compensation costs under a qualified cost-sharing agreement because arm’s length parties would not do so. The Tax Court found that Treasury had inadequately addressed evidence in the notice-and-comment process that parties not under common control did not share stock-based compensation costs, although Treasury explained in the Preamble to the regulation that cost-sharing agreements between uncontrolled parties are not sufficiently comparable to those in controlled-party transactions.
Altera raises an important administrative law question about what is required of Treasury for its regulations to be valid. Susie and Steve spearheaded an amicus brief in the Ninth Circuit in favor of the Commissioner, in which I joined, along with Dick Harvey, Ruth Mason, and Bret Wells. An amicus brief prepared by another group of professors also supports the Commissioner. There are also amicus briefs by business groups on the other side. See Susie and Steve’s blog post for more detail. And for prior coverage on the Surly Subgroup, see this post on our amicus brief, explaining why the Ninth Circuit should reverse the Tax Court’s decision invalidating the regulation.
3 thoughts on “Tomorrow’s Ninth Circuit Oral Argument in Altera”
UPDATE: Susie Morse and Steve Shay have posted a detailed analysis of the oral argument on Procedurally Taxing. See http://procedurallytaxing.com/the-altera-oral-argument/.
2nd UPDATE: And here’s another analysis of the oral argument, this one by Stu Bassin, also on Procedureally Taxing: http://procedurallytaxing.com/a-second-review-of-ninth-circuit-argument-in-altera-v-commissioner/.
The 9th Circuit’s opinion was released this morning! For a brief discussion of it, see https://surlysubgroup.com/2018/07/24/reversing-the-u-s-tax-court-9th-circuit-rules-for-irs-in-altera/.